Nate Sutter is a kid who is friends with Trevor, Summer, and Pigeon. They are the first users of magic candy in Colson, Nate's hometown. They work for Belinda White, but after learning her evil intentions, they change sides, to work for Sebastian Stott. They later defeat Mrs. White, and her brother, Jonas White. Nate has also destroyed Uweya, the simulcrum of the world.

He was the first of the group that truly trusted Mrs. White, and also the last to admit she was up to something fishy. It is implied that his love interest is Summer.